Also on the daily podcast: private tutoring in Asia and celebrating novelist Elias Khoury

Meet the general reinventing America’s army

The Intelligence - Meet the general reinventing America’s army | Podcasts | The Economist

gv_safe

future_of_work_test

neg_jpm_2024q4

ibm_blacklist

neg_jpm

custom_punkt

gb_safe

gb_safe_from_high

gb_safe_from_high_med

pos_goldman_inclusion_2024

pos_israel-hamas_war

gs_science_geography

gs_science

neg_dit

ibm_cloud

ts_tech

neg_fidelity_gmo

gs_books

gs_education

neg_3166_vca_brand-safety

neg_3166_vca_brand-safety1

america_campaigns_elections

america_civil_rights

america_white_house

neg_omd_exclusion

chanel_neg

america_department_commerce

ssga_euro_elections_resiliency

gt_mixed

neg_dit5

neg_google_youtube_2020

cigna_healthyhybridworkplace

business_engineering

gs_science_misc

ge_tech_enthusiasts

General rule: how to reinvent America’s army

iframe

figure

span

small

Twenty years ago America was fighting insurgents in Afghanistan and Iran. As state-on-state clashes become more likely, Randy George is the person in charge of preparing US forces for a new age (9:45). Private tutoring has long been common in East Asia, now it is spreading throughout the continent. And celebrating Lebanese novelist Elias Khoury (17:12).  Runtime: 24 min

Twenty years ago America was fighting insurgents in Afghanistan and Iran. As state-on-state clashes become more likely, <a href="https://www.economist.com/united-states/2024/09/29/the-us-armys-chief-of-staff-has-ideas-on-the-force-of-the-future?utm_campaign=a.io&utm_medium=audio.podcast.np&utm_source=theintelligence&utm_content=discovery.content.anonymous.tr_shownotes_na-na_article&utm_term=sa.listeners" target="_blank">Randy George</a> is the person in charge of preparing US forces for a new age (9:45). <a href="https://www.economist.com/asia/2024/09/19/private-tutoring-is-booming-across-poorer-parts-of-asia?utm_campaign=a.io&utm_medium=audio.podcast.np&utm_source=theintelligence&utm_content=discovery.content.anonymous.tr_shownotes_na-na_article&utm_term=sa.listeners" target="_blank">Private tutoring</a> has long been common in East Asia, now it is spreading throughout the continent. And celebrating Lebanese novelist <a href="https://www.economist.com/obituary/2024/09/25/elias-khoury-encapsulated-the-confusions-of-the-middle-east?utm_campaign=a.io&utm_medium=audio.podcast.np&utm_source=theintelligence&utm_content=discovery.content.anonymous.tr_shownotes_na-na_article&utm_term=sa.listeners" target="_blank">Elias Khoury</a> (17:12).  Runtime: 24 min

Listen on: <a href="https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-intelligence-from-the-economist/id1449631195" target="_blank">Apple Podcasts</a> | <a href="https://open.spotify.com/show/12zKAMNyS2GNentUzxq9QN" target="_blank">Spotify</a>

Listen to what matters most, from global politics and business to science and technology—Subscribe to Economist Podcasts+

Listen to what matters most, from global politics and business to science and technology—<a href="https://subscribenow.economist.com/podcasts-plus" target="_blank">Subscribe to Economist Podcasts+</a>

For more information about how to access Economist Podcasts+, please visit our FAQs page or watch our video explaining how to link your account.

For more information about how to access Economist Podcasts+, please visit our <a href="https://myaccount.economist.com/s/article/What-is-Economist-Podcasts" target="_blank">FAQs page</a> or watch <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gczo71bg1uY" target="_blank">our video </a>explaining how to link your account.

The Intelligence 

This podcast transcript is generated by third-party AI. It has not been reviewed prior to publication. We make no representations or warranties in relation to the transcript, its accuracy or its completeness, and we disclaim all liability regarding its receipt, content and use. If you have any concerns about the transcript, please email us at podcasts@economist.com.

This podcast transcript is generated by third-party AI. It has not been reviewed prior to publication. We make no representations or warranties in relation to the transcript, its accuracy or its completeness, and we disclaim all liability regarding its receipt, content and use. If you have any concerns about the transcript, please email us at <a href="mailto:podcasts@economist.com" target="_blank">podcasts@economist.com.</a>

<a href="https://myaccount.economist.com/s/article/How-we-handle-AI-generated-content" target="_blank">Read more about how we are using AI.</a>

Jason Palmer [00:00:10] Hello and welcome to the intelligence from The Economist. I’m Jason Palmer.

Jason Palmer [00:00:10] Hello and welcome to the intelligence from The Economist. I’m Jason Palmer.

Rosie Blau [00:00:14] And I’m Rosie Blue. Every weekday, we provide a fresh perspective on the events shaping your world.

Rosie Blau [00:00:14] And I’m Rosie Blue. Every weekday, we provide a fresh perspective on the events shaping your world.

Jason Palmer [00:00:24] In Asia, there’s a boom in what experts call an anxiety industry, private tutoring. More than a quarter of a billion students have a tutor, and it’s a feedback loop. The more parents who hire one, the more that other parents think they must.

Jason Palmer [00:00:24] In Asia, there’s a boom in what experts call an anxiety industry, private tutoring. More than a quarter of a billion students have a tutor, and it’s a feedback loop. The more parents who hire one, the more that other parents think they must.

Rosie Blau [00:00:41] And Elias Khoury saw himself as a journalist, an intellectual and a literary critic. Then he wrote a novel, Gate of the Son, which put both him and Lebanon on the map. Our obituaries editor celebrates his life.

Rosie Blau [00:00:41] And Elias Khoury saw himself as a journalist, an intellectual and a literary critic. Then he wrote a novel, Gate of the Son, which put both him and Lebanon on the map. Our obituaries editor celebrates his life.

Jason Palmer [00:01:02] First up, though.

Jason Palmer [00:01:02] First up, though.

Clip [00:01:11] From where we were at the last 20 years, where we weren’t looking up at all understanding what that airspace picture and understanding what’s flying, what’s friendly, what’s not. You know, it’s a very going to be a much more cluttered battlefield with all these systems up.

Clip [00:01:11] From where we were at the last 20 years, where we weren’t looking up at all understanding what that airspace picture and understanding what’s flying, what’s friendly, what’s not. You know, it’s a very going to be a much more cluttered battlefield with all these systems up.

Shashank Joshi [00:01:29] Randy George joined the U.S. Army in 1988, and that was a really interesting time in the Army.

Shashank Joshi [00:01:29] Randy George joined the U.S. Army in 1988, and that was a really interesting time in the Army.

Jason Palmer [00:01:37] Shashank Joshi is the Economist’s defence editor.

Jason Palmer [00:01:37] Shashank Joshi is the Economist’s defence editor.

Shashank Joshi [00:01:40] It was an army that was recovering from the trauma of Vietnam. It had written this new concept called Air Land Battle, about how you might defeat the Soviet Union. And a few years later it sort of got its mojo back when it defeated Iraq in the first Gulf War. That was a war in which George served as a young lieutenant. You know, when I was in Iraq and Afghanistan, if I looked up, you know, I knew that it was going to be our Air Force or one of our U.S. I do think that that has changed. Today, he’s General George and he is in charge of that force. He’s chief of staff of the US Army. He’s been in the job about a year or so and I took that opportunity to chat with him recently about his ideas for how it needs to change, how he’s reinventing it for a new age and how he’s making it basically a much more technological force.

Shashank Joshi [00:01:40] It was an army that was recovering from the trauma of Vietnam. It had written this new concept called Air Land Battle, about how you might defeat the Soviet Union. And a few years later it sort of got its mojo back when it defeated Iraq in the first Gulf War. That was a war in which George served as a young lieutenant. You know, when I was in Iraq and Afghanistan, if I looked up, you know, I knew that it was going to be our Air Force or one of our U.S. I do think that that has changed. Today, he’s General George and he is in charge of that force. He’s chief of staff of the US Army. He’s been in the job about a year or so and I took that opportunity to chat with him recently about his ideas for how it needs to change, how he’s reinventing it for a new age and how he’s making it basically a much more technological force.

Jason Palmer [00:02:32] And what does he think is required for that to happen?

Jason Palmer [00:02:32] And what does he think is required for that to happen?

Shashank Joshi [00:02:34] He’s got several priorities, but fundamentally, it’s about war fighting, which is a kind of way of saying we spent 20 years fighting insurgents in the war on terror, Iraq, Afghanistan, other places. This is now about preparing for a high intensity conflict, perhaps against Russia, perhaps against China. But basically it’s a state on state clash. And the way he put it to me is that the focus is on building what he called lethal and cohesive teams. So part of that is trimming some of the flab, for instance, that built up over those counterinsurgency years. We’ve had brigades that have turned in between 5 and 700 vehicles and trailers and things like that, things that we know that we’re not going to need. And it’s going to give us more time to make sure that we’re focussed on the things that we should be focussed on, the vehicles that are left or being serviced less often, which is accepting a bit of risk, but that leaves more time and resources to train. Ammunition factories are working at full pelt, so they produced 40,000 rounds of one 55 millimetre artillery in August. That’s up about a third from February, and that’s expected to double by this time next year. And the Army’s manpower situation is improving as well. We’ve spent a lot of effort with transforming that whole organisation and how we approach how we’re using more commercial off the shelf products, how we’re picking our recruiters, and so that we’ve made a lot of adjustments to that, how we’re advertising all of those things. So after years of missing recruitment targets last month, the army had a bit of good news. It exceeded its goal for the year by about 10,000 soldiers. That’s a very refreshing change from the way things have gone in the past.

Shashank Joshi [00:02:34] He’s got several priorities, but fundamentally, it’s about war fighting, which is a kind of way of saying we spent 20 years fighting insurgents in the war on terror, Iraq, Afghanistan, other places. This is now about preparing for a high intensity conflict, perhaps against Russia, perhaps against China. But basically it’s a state on state clash. And the way he put it to me is that the focus is on building what he called lethal and cohesive teams. So part of that is trimming some of the flab, for instance, that built up over those counterinsurgency years. We’ve had brigades that have turned in between 5 and 700 vehicles and trailers and things like that, things that we know that we’re not going to need. And it’s going to give us more time to make sure that we’re focussed on the things that we should be focussed on, the vehicles that are left or being serviced less often, which is accepting a bit of risk, but that leaves more time and resources to train. Ammunition factories are working at full pelt, so they produced 40,000 rounds of one 55 millimetre artillery in August. That’s up about a third from February, and that’s expected to double by this time next year. And the Army’s manpower situation is improving as well. We’ve spent a lot of effort with transforming that whole organisation and how we approach how we’re using more commercial off the shelf products, how we’re picking our recruiters, and so that we’ve made a lot of adjustments to that, how we’re advertising all of those things. So after years of missing recruitment targets last month, the army had a bit of good news. It exceeded its goal for the year by about 10,000 soldiers. That’s a very refreshing change from the way things have gone in the past.

Jason Palmer [00:04:17] So is it easy to turn around an army in this way?

Jason Palmer [00:04:17] So is it easy to turn around an army in this way?

Shashank Joshi [00:04:21] I think there’s two big challenges, and one of them is about its focus, which is where the army is looking. The National Defence Strategy for the United States is really explicit. China is the priority, but the army knows that any war over Taiwan or the South China Sea that would involve mainly air and naval forces. The army also has to look at Europe. It has a big presence in Europe. It has big commitments to NATO’s. So is it going to fight Russia or is it going to fight China because you need different types of forces for each adversary. The second challenge is technology. We have very clearly seen, Jason, we’ve talked a lot, in fact, about how the war in Ukraine is illustrating that weapons work really well until the enemy adapts differently. We’re in your you’re fully aware of how much the world is changing has changed just over the last couple of years with where commercial tech is changing and so on. And so America’s GPS guided shells have been blunted by Russian jamming. We see that drones in Ukraine need their software, their sensors, their radios updated every 6 to 12 weeks just to remain effective. You know, I mean, just like your iPhone needs constant updates and things pushed to it. The same is becoming true with weapons.

Shashank Joshi [00:04:21] I think there’s two big challenges, and one of them is about its focus, which is where the army is looking. The National Defence Strategy for the United States is really explicit. China is the priority, but the army knows that any war over Taiwan or the South China Sea that would involve mainly air and naval forces. The army also has to look at Europe. It has a big presence in Europe. It has big commitments to NATO’s. So is it going to fight Russia or is it going to fight China because you need different types of forces for each adversary. The second challenge is technology. We have very clearly seen, Jason, we’ve talked a lot, in fact, about how the war in Ukraine is illustrating that weapons work really well until the enemy adapts differently. We’re in your you’re fully aware of how much the world is changing has changed just over the last couple of years with where commercial tech is changing and so on. And so America’s GPS guided shells have been blunted by Russian jamming. We see that drones in Ukraine need their software, their sensors, their radios updated every 6 to 12 weeks just to remain effective. You know, I mean, just like your iPhone needs constant updates and things pushed to it. The same is becoming true with weapons.

Jason Palmer [00:05:35] And how is General George dealing with those challenges?

Jason Palmer [00:05:35] And how is General George dealing with those challenges?

Shashank Joshi [00:05:38] Well, there’s a lot of ways. I think one of the interesting ones is a scheme called transforming in contact these brigades based on how the changing battlefield. And then we’ve handed over this structure to the unit. And then so they’ve picked three brigades to serve as kind of laboratories for innovation, and they’ve chosen these carefully. One of these brigades is in Alaska, and it’s Pacific facing for contingencies in Asia. One of them is in continental United States and the other one is in Germany. So what’s Europe facing? And they each are receiving the newest kit, the best kit. And they test it. They test it not just on sterile exercises in big Midwestern American bases, but they test it in the field and they give feedback on what works, what doesn’t. And this is a big change for how things have gone in the past, right? In the past, the Army would spell out page upon page of requirements for we need this drone to work in -20°C in 60°C. We need it to be able to cope with all of these situations. And it would be overengineered, it would be gold plated, and they would push that stuff down to every unit in the army over a long period, 3 to 7 years. These experimental brigades, Jason, they can buy stuff quickly. They can buy stuff that suits their environment and they can work out whether it’s working or whether it needs refinement or change. Where we have users, developers and testers that are all there together and we’re spinning the wheel, I think, much, much quicker. And so the days of basically picking one company, getting them to build something for ten years and keeping it for another 20 years, that’s over. The future is modular systems that can change fast.

Shashank Joshi [00:05:38] Well, there’s a lot of ways. I think one of the interesting ones is a scheme called transforming in contact these brigades based on how the changing battlefield. And then we’ve handed over this structure to the unit. And then so they’ve picked three brigades to serve as kind of laboratories for innovation, and they’ve chosen these carefully. One of these brigades is in Alaska, and it’s Pacific facing for contingencies in Asia. One of them is in continental United States and the other one is in Germany. So what’s Europe facing? And they each are receiving the newest kit, the best kit. And they test it. They test it not just on sterile exercises in big Midwestern American bases, but they test it in the field and they give feedback on what works, what doesn’t. And this is a big change for how things have gone in the past, right? In the past, the Army would spell out page upon page of requirements for we need this drone to work in -20°C in 60°C. We need it to be able to cope with all of these situations. And it would be overengineered, it would be gold plated, and they would push that stuff down to every unit in the army over a long period, 3 to 7 years. These experimental brigades, Jason, they can buy stuff quickly. They can buy stuff that suits their environment and they can work out whether it’s working or whether it needs refinement or change. Where we have users, developers and testers that are all there together and we’re spinning the wheel, I think, much, much quicker. And so the days of basically picking one company, getting them to build something for ten years and keeping it for another 20 years, that’s over. The future is modular systems that can change fast.

Jason Palmer [00:07:19] And do you have a sense whether all of this change is working or will we not know until a grand conflict comes?

Jason Palmer [00:07:19] And do you have a sense whether all of this change is working or will we not know until a grand conflict comes?

Shashank Joshi [00:07:25] I think the jury’s out and I talk to a lot of army chiefs, military chiefs, and you hear the same buzzwords out of all of them. Right. It’s innovation, experimentation. We’ve got to procure more quickly. We’ve got to do spiral development, not just buying big things and leaving them. They all understand what the problem is. I’m not entirely convinced they have all cracked the solution, but I am seeing signs of change. There’s an interesting instance that General George told me about where the Army needed covers for coolant pumps on Bradley armoured vehicles, and it was told these are going to take 6 to 8 months. And so what they worked out is, hey, we can 3D print these parts. And instead of 6 to 8 months, they printed off 20 of these coolant pump covers in less than an hour at about $0.16 each, which is pretty impressive, I think. Having said all of that, Jason, look, if you talk to Army insiders, they will absolutely acknowledge the procurement system, the system for buying things and fielding them. That’s still broken. It’s still constrained by suffocating Pentagon rules, by suffocating legislation imposed by Congress. There is still a lot of frustration.

Shashank Joshi [00:07:25] I think the jury’s out and I talk to a lot of army chiefs, military chiefs, and you hear the same buzzwords out of all of them. Right. It’s innovation, experimentation. We’ve got to procure more quickly. We’ve got to do spiral development, not just buying big things and leaving them. They all understand what the problem is. I’m not entirely convinced they have all cracked the solution, but I am seeing signs of change. There’s an interesting instance that General George told me about where the Army needed covers for coolant pumps on Bradley armoured vehicles, and it was told these are going to take 6 to 8 months. And so what they worked out is, hey, we can 3D print these parts. And instead of 6 to 8 months, they printed off 20 of these coolant pump covers in less than an hour at about $0.16 each, which is pretty impressive, I think. Having said all of that, Jason, look, if you talk to Army insiders, they will absolutely acknowledge the procurement system, the system for buying things and fielding them. That’s still broken. It’s still constrained by suffocating Pentagon rules, by suffocating legislation imposed by Congress. There is still a lot of frustration.

Jason Palmer [00:08:34] But you got the sense from General George that he’s confident the change can will happen.

Jason Palmer [00:08:34] But you got the sense from General George that he’s confident the change can will happen.

Shashank Joshi [00:08:39] I think the big challenge is scaling it up in the British army, the US Army. I see these pockets of experimentation. The big concern is can you scale this up? When I talk to soldiers in the UK and European armies in the US Army, the thing they say to me is how is it that we are able to help Ukraine do these amazing things, build these Frankenstein systems, cobbled together building these incredibly novel naval drones, strapping together this sort of battlefield AI.

Shashank Joshi [00:08:39] I think the big challenge is scaling it up in the British army, the US Army. I see these pockets of experimentation. The big concern is can you scale this up? When I talk to soldiers in the UK and European armies in the US Army, the thing they say to me is how is it that we are able to help Ukraine do these amazing things, build these Frankenstein systems, cobbled together building these incredibly novel naval drones, strapping together this sort of battlefield AI.

Shashank Joshi [00:09:13] But we are unable.

Shashank Joshi [00:09:13] But we are unable.

Shashank Joshi [00:09:15] To procure this stuff and field it in our own formations at scale at Accenture. Double cost. And I think that that is going to be one of the key tests. When are we going to see a U.S. Army that is a little bit more Ukrainian?

Shashank Joshi [00:09:15] To procure this stuff and field it in our own formations at scale at Accenture. Double cost. And I think that that is going to be one of the key tests. When are we going to see a U.S. Army that is a little bit more Ukrainian?

Jason Palmer [00:09:31] Shashank, thanks very much for your time.

Jason Palmer [00:09:31] Shashank, thanks very much for your time.

Shashank Joshi [00:09:32] Thanks, Jason.

Ethan Wu [00:09:47] Last year, Bollywood released a hit film called 12 Fail.

Ethan Wu [00:09:47] Last year, Bollywood released a hit film called 12 Fail.

Rosie Blau [00:09:51] Ethan Wu is our Asia correspondent.

Rosie Blau [00:09:51] Ethan Wu is our Asia correspondent.

Ethan Wu [00:09:54] It’s a somewhat sappy story of a poor farm boy who’s bent on becoming a police civil servant in India up to be filled with it. Don’t waste our time, Jia. But for a film that’s at the end of the day about education and meritocracy and pulling yourself up by your bootstraps, Indian schools don’t end up being portrayed that positively. They are corrupt and they’re rife with cheating, facilitated by the very teachers that run the school. The centrepiece of the movie and where mentors would eventually find success. And love is not at school but at a tutoring centre. People may know about fast growth in private tutoring in an East Asian context. People have heard about cram centres in Korea and Hong Kong and Taiwan driving a cram culture. But what’s less known is that outside of East Asia, where those coaching centres do exist, with world beating educational systems in the rest of Asia, in poorer parts of Asia, private tutoring is on the rise too. And it’s in places where the education system is neither well funded nor functioning well.

Ethan Wu [00:09:54] It’s a somewhat sappy story of a poor farm boy who’s bent on becoming a police civil servant in India up to be filled with it. Don’t waste our time, Jia. But for a film that’s at the end of the day about education and meritocracy and pulling yourself up by your bootstraps, Indian schools don’t end up being portrayed that positively. They are corrupt and they’re rife with cheating, facilitated by the very teachers that run the school. The centrepiece of the movie and where mentors would eventually find success. And love is not at school but at a tutoring centre. People may know about fast growth in private tutoring in an East Asian context. People have heard about cram centres in Korea and Hong Kong and Taiwan driving a cram culture. But what’s less known is that outside of East Asia, where those coaching centres do exist, with world beating educational systems in the rest of Asia, in poorer parts of Asia, private tutoring is on the rise too. And it’s in places where the education system is neither well funded nor functioning well.

Rosie Blau [00:10:56] Ethan, can you give me some details here? Where is it rising and by how much?

Rosie Blau [00:10:56] Ethan, can you give me some details here? Where is it rising and by how much?

Ethan Wu [00:11:01] Well, the hard part about answering that question, Rosy, is the data is just so poor. But we’ve had a crack at trying to put some figures to it. And what were able to come up with is about 258 million children in South and Southeast Asia take private tuition. If you exclude Singapore, which tends to share more similarities with East Asia. India is certainly the biggest market there in rural areas, 31% of schoolchildren under 15 years old take private tutoring, which is an increase from 23% in 2010. And that’s in rural areas. In urban areas, prevalence is even higher. And India wide prevalence is estimated at something like 50%. So half of Indian children in school and as you might expect, given all the student attention, the Indian tutoring industry is booming. Tax revenue from tutoring centres has more than doubled since 2019. But the phenomenon is much broader than India by our estimation. If you take out India from the South and Southeast Asia total, you still get 131 million children that are involved in this space.

Ethan Wu [00:11:01] Well, the hard part about answering that question, Rosy, is the data is just so poor. But we’ve had a crack at trying to put some figures to it. And what were able to come up with is about 258 million children in South and Southeast Asia take private tuition. If you exclude Singapore, which tends to share more similarities with East Asia. India is certainly the biggest market there in rural areas, 31% of schoolchildren under 15 years old take private tutoring, which is an increase from 23% in 2010. And that’s in rural areas. In urban areas, prevalence is even higher. And India wide prevalence is estimated at something like 50%. So half of Indian children in school and as you might expect, given all the student attention, the Indian tutoring industry is booming. Tax revenue from tutoring centres has more than doubled since 2019. But the phenomenon is much broader than India by our estimation. If you take out India from the South and Southeast Asia total, you still get 131 million children that are involved in this space.

Rosie Blau [00:11:59] Is this a very recent rise and why are we seeing this trend?

Rosie Blau [00:11:59] Is this a very recent rise and why are we seeing this trend?

Ethan Wu [00:12:02] The rise has been accentuated in the last decade, but we are seeing a longer term trend that’s taking place over several decades. And it’s driven by three things. First is gaps left in the formal education systems. What we’ve seen in poorer parts of Asia is more demands on the state for educational resources. More and more children are in secondary school. Almost all children are in some form of primary school all across the world and certainly in Asia. But at the same time, resources have not kept up. Education spending as a share of GDP has been flat to down in many of the countries that we looked at. And so what you have is schools that are not always equipped to give students the tools they need to succeed in an increasingly competitive domestic economy and increasingly competitive world. So what parents do to help their children on high stakes exams, especially for universities, is turn to tutors. The second is what I mentioned earlier heightens social competition. Labour markets demand more skills than ever before. Things like urbanisation that push people into cities create a bit of a rat race dynamic. The third factor is an arms race, and this is somewhere where East Asia and South and Southeast Asia have a lot in common. Once your neighbours child starts taking private tutoring, if yours doesn’t, yours is behind by definition. And this is why academics call private tutoring and anxiety industry. It feeds off perceptions of falling behind if you don’t purchase the product. And it leads to prevalence only going in one direction, which is up.

Ethan Wu [00:12:02] The rise has been accentuated in the last decade, but we are seeing a longer term trend that’s taking place over several decades. And it’s driven by three things. First is gaps left in the formal education systems. What we’ve seen in poorer parts of Asia is more demands on the state for educational resources. More and more children are in secondary school. Almost all children are in some form of primary school all across the world and certainly in Asia. But at the same time, resources have not kept up. Education spending as a share of GDP has been flat to down in many of the countries that we looked at. And so what you have is schools that are not always equipped to give students the tools they need to succeed in an increasingly competitive domestic economy and increasingly competitive world. So what parents do to help their children on high stakes exams, especially for universities, is turn to tutors. The second is what I mentioned earlier heightens social competition. Labour markets demand more skills than ever before. Things like urbanisation that push people into cities create a bit of a rat race dynamic. The third factor is an arms race, and this is somewhere where East Asia and South and Southeast Asia have a lot in common. Once your neighbours child starts taking private tutoring, if yours doesn’t, yours is behind by definition. And this is why academics call private tutoring and anxiety industry. It feeds off perceptions of falling behind if you don’t purchase the product. And it leads to prevalence only going in one direction, which is up.

Rosie Blau [00:13:30] We tend to think of more education as a good thing. So what is the problem if parents are turning to private tuition?

Rosie Blau [00:13:30] We tend to think of more education as a good thing. So what is the problem if parents are turning to private tuition?

Ethan Wu [00:13:38] Right. Education is a good thing and it’s entirely natural for parents to want to get their own children ahead. There’s nothing wrong in that. The problem is, when you look at society wide effects, a big rise in private tutoring can have negative impacts. We spoke with one parent who’s a supervisor at a generator manufacturer in Old Delhi who pays an increase of 30% on his usual school fees for private tutoring for his two daughters. That highlights a big downside to private tutoring, which is just the expense to parents. But that’s not all. The stress to children is absolutely real. In India last year, in one city alone, there were dozens of student suicides, which led at least one school to install suicide proof ceiling fans after a series of hangings. The stress has very negative impacts on students mental health, and it also impacts more widely their sleep. Research has shown that students enrolled in private tutoring have worse sleep with implications for their health more broadly. And then there’s a question as to whether private tutoring drains the public sector’s ability to deliver essential educational services. This is hard to establish systematically. But some scholars have pointed to examples where schools have essentially outsourced their core educational functions to private tutoring. And this is especially the case when resources are scarce and governments simply can’t provide those services.

Ethan Wu [00:13:38] Right. Education is a good thing and it’s entirely natural for parents to want to get their own children ahead. There’s nothing wrong in that. The problem is, when you look at society wide effects, a big rise in private tutoring can have negative impacts. We spoke with one parent who’s a supervisor at a generator manufacturer in Old Delhi who pays an increase of 30% on his usual school fees for private tutoring for his two daughters. That highlights a big downside to private tutoring, which is just the expense to parents. But that’s not all. The stress to children is absolutely real. In India last year, in one city alone, there were dozens of student suicides, which led at least one school to install suicide proof ceiling fans after a series of hangings. The stress has very negative impacts on students mental health, and it also impacts more widely their sleep. Research has shown that students enrolled in private tutoring have worse sleep with implications for their health more broadly. And then there’s a question as to whether private tutoring drains the public sector’s ability to deliver essential educational services. This is hard to establish systematically. But some scholars have pointed to examples where schools have essentially outsourced their core educational functions to private tutoring. And this is especially the case when resources are scarce and governments simply can’t provide those services.

Rosie Blau [00:14:58] Those are some pretty terrifying conclusions. Is there actually a positive impact on exam results to the kids? Learn a lot.

Rosie Blau [00:14:58] Those are some pretty terrifying conclusions. Is there actually a positive impact on exam results to the kids? Learn a lot.

Ethan Wu [00:15:05] Right. So if the story was students are stressed and parents are paying a lot, but they’re doing better on tests, then in some ways it would be a little bit easier to say, well, the downsides are tough, but education is getting what you expect from education. The problem is it’s hard to establish that tutoring systematically helps students learn effectively. Mark Bray, who’s the foremost scholar of Asian private tutoring, says evidence is at best mixed. And this is an assessment shared by many scholars in the field. And the problem is that we’re using this term private tutoring. But what actually counts as private tutoring is incredibly diverse. It ranges from online services to in-person coaching centres to university students helping school age children at cafes. It’s far too broad to really pin down as one particular thing. And that means it’s hard to know if all the money in the attention and frankly, the stress and the lost sleep going into tutoring is really having a positive impacts. I think at best we can say it’s mixed.

Ethan Wu [00:15:05] Right. So if the story was students are stressed and parents are paying a lot, but they’re doing better on tests, then in some ways it would be a little bit easier to say, well, the downsides are tough, but education is getting what you expect from education. The problem is it’s hard to establish that tutoring systematically helps students learn effectively. Mark Bray, who’s the foremost scholar of Asian private tutoring, says evidence is at best mixed. And this is an assessment shared by many scholars in the field. And the problem is that we’re using this term private tutoring. But what actually counts as private tutoring is incredibly diverse. It ranges from online services to in-person coaching centres to university students helping school age children at cafes. It’s far too broad to really pin down as one particular thing. And that means it’s hard to know if all the money in the attention and frankly, the stress and the lost sleep going into tutoring is really having a positive impacts. I think at best we can say it’s mixed.

Rosie Blau [00:16:02] It’s famously hard to stop arms races escalating. How do we stop the tutoring arms race from continuing then?

Rosie Blau [00:16:02] It’s famously hard to stop arms races escalating. How do we stop the tutoring arms race from continuing then?

Ethan Wu [00:16:10] Well, this is the problem, isn’t it, In societies that have been grappling with the effects of private tutoring for decades, like South Korea, attempts to suppress the sector simply haven’t worked. A senior Korean government minister told a researcher that after years of personally grappling with how to regulate private tutoring, he concluded that the market was just infinitely more creative than the state. It understands parent psychology is better. It can adapt to new rule making. And this is the fundamental problem with punitive approaches to private tutoring like we saw in China in 2021, which instituted a massive crackdown on the sector. Demand is organic, it’s strong, and it’s deeply socially entrenched, where supply is highly adaptable and can shift to any legal regime that it needs to. And those two dynamics make it extremely hard for governments to confront tutoring head on.

Ethan Wu [00:16:10] Well, this is the problem, isn’t it, In societies that have been grappling with the effects of private tutoring for decades, like South Korea, attempts to suppress the sector simply haven’t worked. A senior Korean government minister told a researcher that after years of personally grappling with how to regulate private tutoring, he concluded that the market was just infinitely more creative than the state. It understands parent psychology is better. It can adapt to new rule making. And this is the fundamental problem with punitive approaches to private tutoring like we saw in China in 2021, which instituted a massive crackdown on the sector. Demand is organic, it’s strong, and it’s deeply socially entrenched, where supply is highly adaptable and can shift to any legal regime that it needs to. And those two dynamics make it extremely hard for governments to confront tutoring head on.

Rosie Blau [00:16:58] Ethan, it’s great to talk to you. Thank you so much.

Rosie Blau [00:16:58] Ethan, it’s great to talk to you. Thank you so much.

Ethan Wu [00:17:01] Thanks for having me.

Ethan Wu [00:17:01] Thanks for having me.

Ann Wroe [00:17:15] In India’s Qureshi’s most celebrated novel, The Gate of the Sun. He described a woman whom Hassan going back to her village. Andrew is the Economist’s obituaries editor. She had fled from his village when Jewish migrants moved in in 1948 as they were founding the new state of Israel. She had been in a refugee camp, but she went back and looked round the old house, the old garden. And in the end, when she plucked up courage, she let her brother knock on the door. It was opened by a dark skinned woman who invited them in and was very welcoming and made coffee for them. And Omar Hassan noticed that even her old earthenware water jug was in its place. The woman, however, was Jewish, although she spoke Arabic, and she said that Omar has and could take the water jab if she wanted. As a souvenir, Hazan went to do that, picked it up, and then suddenly thought she would give it to her. And they both said thank you to each other. Eddie Haskell. He hadn’t witnessed this strange little scene. He had picked it out when he visited the refugee camps of Sabra and Shatila, two huge camps just near Beirut, where the Palestinians were gathered fairly miserably together. There were several stories or many of this sort. The boy whose hair turned white when he’d witnessed a massacre and another of an old woman who had died, still fretting that she’d left a pan of zucchini cooking on the stove. He gathered them all together and didn’t know what to do with them until he wrote his novel The Age of the Sun. Suddenly, he was in a different place and quite an unusual place for a Lebanese, because Lebanese literature was, up until then, mostly a poetical one. But he felt very strongly that writers should portray the truth of the society they were in. Identity was very confused in his region. His principal novel featured a Palestinian who is pretending to be Israeli to impress girlfriends, and his own identity was mixed as well. He was a Lebanese, but his mother was Christian, and his whole background culture was Islamic. So he read the Koran as well as going to church. He and his mother, between them, devoured the thousand and one nights. The thousand and one Nights actually became the model for much of his novel writing. He loved to present the truth from multiple points of view, multiple stories. Just as Shahrazad had done when she was beguiling. The Sultan not to kill her. This, he felt, was the way to tell things as they really were. His chief cause was always the Palestinians. When he was 16 or so, he joined Fatah, which was a militant wing of the Palestine Liberation Organisation. And when the Civil War later broke out in Lebanon, which was actually a civil war caused by disputes over how the Palestinian refugees should be supported, he went off to fight. But almost immediately, he was wounded in his right eye, as if fate was trying to tell him that his duty was not to go to war, but actually to stay and tell the truth about the situation. He did speak out, sometimes in favour of a two state solution for Palestine and Israel. But his take was always that it was not the land of Palestine that was sacred to him as much as Palestinians themselves. He sympathised to an extraordinary degree with them. Although since he was Lebanese himself, some of the Palestinians wondered why he thought he had the right to tell stories about Palestine at all. In his view, he had done all the research that was necessary to speak out on the Palestinian side. He worked for a long time at the Palestinian Research Centre in Beirut, and then he looked into the history of the camps and he took down all the details of the miseries of the people there by hearing their stories and also by poring over the records. And he carefully noted all the topography of the camps so that he could tell the stories as accurately as he could. He wrote a good deal about the horror and miseries of the refugee camps and bore the suffering of the Palestinians in his mind continually. But Lebanon was no haven from this. The refugee camps were there, and Beirut itself had suffered terribly from a number of tragedies. First of all, the civil war, which lasted for 15 years. Then the Israeli bombing of 1982. And then in 2020, a huge explosion in the port which devastated large part of the city. He had loved Beirut when he was growing up there, had fallen in love with the old houses, the olive groves on the outskirts, the cafes, the falafel. Everything about it. But since all those catastrophes, it had become a shadow. He continued to make it his home. But as early as 1993, he imagined that a stranger might come back one day, not long in the future, to bear fruit and find that the city had simply vanished away.

Ann Wroe [00:17:15] In India’s Qureshi’s most celebrated novel, The Gate of the Sun. He described a woman whom Hassan going back to her village. Andrew is the Economist’s obituaries editor. She had fled from his village when Jewish migrants moved in in 1948 as they were founding the new state of Israel. She had been in a refugee camp, but she went back and looked round the old house, the old garden. And in the end, when she plucked up courage, she let her brother knock on the door. It was opened by a dark skinned woman who invited them in and was very welcoming and made coffee for them. And Omar Hassan noticed that even her old earthenware water jug was in its place. The woman, however, was Jewish, although she spoke Arabic, and she said that Omar has and could take the water jab if she wanted. As a souvenir, Hazan went to do that, picked it up, and then suddenly thought she would give it to her. And they both said thank you to each other. Eddie Haskell. He hadn’t witnessed this strange little scene. He had picked it out when he visited the refugee camps of Sabra and Shatila, two huge camps just near Beirut, where the Palestinians were gathered fairly miserably together. There were several stories or many of this sort. The boy whose hair turned white when he’d witnessed a massacre and another of an old woman who had died, still fretting that she’d left a pan of zucchini cooking on the stove. He gathered them all together and didn’t know what to do with them until he wrote his novel The Age of the Sun. Suddenly, he was in a different place and quite an unusual place for a Lebanese, because Lebanese literature was, up until then, mostly a poetical one. But he felt very strongly that writers should portray the truth of the society they were in. Identity was very confused in his region. His principal novel featured a Palestinian who is pretending to be Israeli to impress girlfriends, and his own identity was mixed as well. He was a Lebanese, but his mother was Christian, and his whole background culture was Islamic. So he read the Koran as well as going to church. He and his mother, between them, devoured the thousand and one nights. The thousand and one Nights actually became the model for much of his novel writing. He loved to present the truth from multiple points of view, multiple stories. Just as Shahrazad had done when she was beguiling. The Sultan not to kill her. This, he felt, was the way to tell things as they really were. His chief cause was always the Palestinians. When he was 16 or so, he joined Fatah, which was a militant wing of the Palestine Liberation Organisation. And when the Civil War later broke out in Lebanon, which was actually a civil war caused by disputes over how the Palestinian refugees should be supported, he went off to fight. But almost immediately, he was wounded in his right eye, as if fate was trying to tell him that his duty was not to go to war, but actually to stay and tell the truth about the situation. He did speak out, sometimes in favour of a two state solution for Palestine and Israel. But his take was always that it was not the land of Palestine that was sacred to him as much as Palestinians themselves. He sympathised to an extraordinary degree with them. Although since he was Lebanese himself, some of the Palestinians wondered why he thought he had the right to tell stories about Palestine at all. In his view, he had done all the research that was necessary to speak out on the Palestinian side. He worked for a long time at the Palestinian Research Centre in Beirut, and then he looked into the history of the camps and he took down all the details of the miseries of the people there by hearing their stories and also by poring over the records. And he carefully noted all the topography of the camps so that he could tell the stories as accurately as he could. He wrote a good deal about the horror and miseries of the refugee camps and bore the suffering of the Palestinians in his mind continually. But Lebanon was no haven from this. The refugee camps were there, and Beirut itself had suffered terribly from a number of tragedies. First of all, the civil war, which lasted for 15 years. Then the Israeli bombing of 1982. And then in 2020, a huge explosion in the port which devastated large part of the city. He had loved Beirut when he was growing up there, had fallen in love with the old houses, the olive groves on the outskirts, the cafes, the falafel. Everything about it. But since all those catastrophes, it had become a shadow. He continued to make it his home. But as early as 1993, he imagined that a stranger might come back one day, not long in the future, to bear fruit and find that the city had simply vanished away.

Rosie Blau [00:23:49] Ann Wroe on Alias. Houry, who has died aged 76.

Rosie Blau [00:23:49] Ann Wroe on Alias. Houry, who has died aged 76.

Rosie Blau [00:24:03] That’s it for this episode of the Intelligence. But of course, there’s so much more to listen to. With a subscription to Economist podcast, plus you have access to all our shows. Subscribing helps make our journalism possible. So thank you. Search Economist Podcast Plus for a free trial. And if you have any comments on today’s show, you can get in touch at podcasts@economist.com. We’ll see you back here tomorrow.

Rosie Blau [00:24:03] That’s it for this episode of the Intelligence. But of course, there’s so much more to listen to. With a subscription to Economist podcast, plus you have access to all our shows. Subscribing helps make our journalism possible. So thank you. Search Economist Podcast Plus for a free trial. And if you have any comments on today’s show, you can get in touch at podcasts@economist.com. We’ll see you back here tomorrow.

Podcasts

Drum Tower

Why Chinese migrants are crossing dangerous jungle to reach America

How October 7th shattered the Middle East

People hold hands at a memorial event marking the one-year anniversary of the Hamas attack in southern Israel, in Tel Aviv, on October 7, 2024

The Weekend Intelligence

Black Boxes (part two)

Black Boxes (part one)

Checks and Balance

Who’s winning in Pennsylvania?

Money Talks

Will America’s realtors change their ways?

A "For Sale" sign is posted in front of a home in Sacramento, California, USA

Editorials, columns, guest opinions and your letters, all in one place

Sign up to our Opinion newsletter

Opinion

A behind-the-scenes look at how we chose and designed this week’s cover

How we chose this week’s cover image

Cover Story

Catch up quickly on the global stories that matter

Sign up to enjoy a mind-expanding mix of stories, delivered six days a week

Catch up quickly on the stories that matter

The World in Brief

A sharp round-up of the most important US political news

Sign up for updates from our correspondents and data journalists, poll tracker and election-forecast model as the 2024 race unfolds

The US in brief

Highlights from the latest weekly issue, introduced by our editor

The Economist this week

The very best of our journalism, handpicked for you each weekday

A daily newsletter with the best of our journalism

Handpicked stories, in your inbox

The Economist today

Your essential guide to global business and technology

From supply chains to semiconductors, The Bottom Line newsletter has you covered

Need to track the megatrends shaping business and technology?

The Bottom Line

Expert analysis of the biggest stories in economics and markets

Exclusive insight from our correspondents in America

Exclusive insight and reading recommendations from our correspondents in America

Analysing the challenges facing Britain and what needs to be done to overcome them

Stay informed with our weekly Britain newsletter

Blighty

The best of The Economist’s defence coverage, in one place

The War Room

Understand a vast and complicated country that will increasingly shape the future

Stay informed with our weekly India newsletter

Essential India

Understand what the world makes of China—and what China makes of the world

Stay informed with our weekly China newsletter

Inside Europe, from the front lines in Ukraine to the corridors of power in Brussels

Stay informed with our weekly Europe newsletter

Café Europa

A weekly fix of our mind-expanding science coverage

Curious about the world? Enjoy a weekly fix of our mind-expanding science coverage

Simply Science

A weekly conversation about culture. Because culture is a serious business

Exploring trends and connections across entertainment, the arts and politics

Broaden your perspective with our weekly culture newsletter

Plot Twist

Weekly insights into a continent that is reshaping our world

Our weekly newsletter will help you make sense of the sweeping changes taking place across Africa

Exclusive insights into a continent that is reshaping our world

Analysing Africa

Get to grips with a region where capital, climate and geopolitics collide

Go deeper with our Middle East newsletter. Every week our correspondents delve into the political, social and economic stories of a region that is rarely out of the news.