Leaders | Shake up, not break up

Dismantling Google is a terrible idea

Despite its appeal as a political rallying cry

The illustration depicts a large judge's gavel about to hit the Google logo
Photograph: Rose Wong

The parallels draw themselves. In 1999 America’s government prevailed in a high-profile antitrust suit against a tech giant it alleged was abusing a monopoly. The case then turned on the “power of the default” in internet browsers: Uncle Sam said Microsoft was forcing computer-makers to distribute its browser along with its Windows software. It resulted in proposals to break Microsoft up (though the firm won on appeal and remained whole).

Explore more

This article appeared in the Leaders section of the print edition under the headline “Shake up, not break up”

From the October 5th 2024 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

Discover more

Neural connection, with an electric bolt travellingacross, trailing a little fruit fly.

A map of a fruit fly’s brain could help us understand our own

A miracle of complexity, powered by rotting fruit

Shigeru Ishiba holds a press conference  in Tokyo, Japan on September 27th 2024

Socially liberal and strong on defence, Japan’s new premier shows promise

But he must ditch his more eccentric ideas if he is to control his party


An electronic ticker displays stock figures in Shanghai, China, on August 7th 2024

Don’t celebrate China’s stimulus just yet

It will take more than a spectacular stockmarket rally to revive the economy


The year that shattered the Middle East

Kill or be killed is the region’s new logic. Deterrence and diplomacy would be better

YouTube’s do-it-yourself brigade is taking on Netflix and Disney

Legions of self-taught film-makers are coming for the television industry